To keep my promise from my last post, I will write about the person who guessed the source of the quotation. To everyone who did not immediately think King Lear, or at least, Doesn’t Kelly like King Lear?, I am disappointed; to my mother, who did, I offer congratulations.
One character trait which has always puzzled and intrigued me is my mother’s apparent sense of discernment. She can sense a lie like nobody’s business, whether she knows the person well or not at all. (You can imagine how distressing this was for me growing up: She would know whether I dipped into the proverbial cookie jar the moment I tried to deny it.) Sometimes a person might be interviewed on television, and my mother will know whether there is “something wrong.” She has described it variously as a discomfort of her spirit or an emotional sense of wrongness. She doesn’t necessarily know what the truth is, but she knows it isn’t what is being said.
For us creatures not magically gifted with an innate sense of truth (and you’ll have to take my word that she’s been proven right too many times to be questioned), what we must rely on is our knowledge of sociology, human nature, and other motivating factors. I can tell whether someone is lying if he begins breathing quickly, looks away, fidgets; and I can guess why and about what if I know his history, circumstances, or particular loyalties. This is not the kind of lie-detection I’m talking about. It is a reaction of the gut…or of the spirit.
Perhaps her talent has this as its source:
And there are varieties of ministries, and the same Lord. …But to each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good. For to one is given the word of wisdom through the Spirit, and to another …the distinguishing of spirits. (NASB, 1 Cor. 12:5-10.)
I’ve always thought that this ‘distinguishing’ or discernment was a strange gift, more out of a fantasy novel than part of real life. What good is it to sense the truth if you have no king to warn away from the poison, or no evil wizard to cheat out of his gold? More seriously, what good is it to know the truth when you can’t prove the person’s lie, or when you aren’t supposed to judge him anyway?
Not having this gift myself (I can put to rest your concerns that it might be hereditary), I’m not certain what kind of responsibility, or lack thereof, would come with it. Does the reference to the ‘common good’ imply some sort of obligation to actually distinguish between the spirits for the sake of others? Or is the private distinction sufficient?
I’m not certain; I don’t know – and, truth be told, a little relieved about it. Spiritual gifts can be far too deep and mysterious for me. Sometimes I wish I knew mine, but then again,
Everyone to whom much was given, of him much will be required, and from him to whom they entrusted much, they will demand the more. (Luke 12:48.)
(Sorry, I didn’t mean to be so ominous. :-P)
On a lighter note, I had chicken fajitas tonight and laughed myself to tears over The Sparrow. I think the ethical and moral pondering of Mary Doria Russell has insinuated itself into my post.