In my recent quest to read through my backlog of books, I remembered a title I’ve had for a decade: The Forest for the Trees: An Editor’s Advice to Writers by Betsy Lerner.
I vividly remember purchasing this book as an early teenager. I had just made the miraculous discovery that people wrote books about writing (an obsession that has grown to the size of three shelves full of writers-on-writing acquisitions) but I hadn’t the faintest idea about which ones were worth anything. So I asked a bookseller at the independent bookstore I used to frequent, and she handed me this one.
Which, as it turns out, was not at all what I was looking for at the time. I needed something about mechanics and also discovering style, but I was too ignorant to know it. So I took the book home, flipped through it, and realized instantly it was not right for me, and thus it sat on my shelf for ten years.
It was written by an ex-poet turned editor who knows a thing or two about authors. Part one, which is all I’ve read so far, is about different types of authors: the ambivalent one who doesn’t know what to write, the shameless self-promoter, the so-called natural writer, and so forth. Each of these has strengths and weaknesses, and Lerner runs a kind of diagnostic about each type. If this is you, here’s some advice to make things go a bit more smoothly. Some of the advice is applicable, some not, but all of it is entertaining.
Part two, which I’m rather looking forward to, is about the business of writing, about the author-editor relationship. I hope Lerner has some tips about professionalism, a kind of What to Expect timeline for editing a novel after it’s been purchased by a publisher. In any case, this book seems just right for me now, ten years later.
All of this is really just an exemplary argument for why I should go ahead and buy it: I really will read it eventually.